Psychiatric Diagnosis

The Diagnostic Process

There are essentially only three parts to making a psychiatric diagnosis: 

  1. gathering information about your recent and past history of symptoms 
  2. observing your behavior and emotions during the interview and 
  3. ruling out physical causes of your symptoms.

1. Gathering Information about Symptoms

The present and past history of your symptoms is determined from your answers to questions such as, "How have you been sleeping compared to usual?" "Do you ever hear any sounds, noises or voices, that other people don't hear?" "Has there ever been time when your friends or family said something about your drinking?" There is nothing very complicated or mysterious about the questions used to make your psychiatric diagnosis. It is simply a matter of knowing the symptoms your diagnosis is based on, and knowing how to "translate" the psychiatric jargon into questions using everyday language. A good interviewer will ask you questions that you understand; a bad interviewer will use too many technical terms.

2. Observing Behavior and Emotions

Because observation is an important part of every evaluation your psychiatric evaluation actually begins when you are greeted by your clinician. Diagnostic clues can be found in how fast you talk (people with mania often talk rapidly and are difficult to interrupt; people with depression may speak slowly and softly with extended pauses before answering questions), how you relate to the interviewer (people with schizophrenia may be distant and detached, whereas people with mania or certain personality disorders may be overly familiar and sexually seductive), or how well you can focus on the interview (a person hearing voices might look up to the ceiling and appear as if she is hearing someone, even though she may initially deny the reason for this behavior). 

You may have a psychiatric disorder that is associated with observable physical abnormalities. A skin abrasion on one or two fingers maybe seen if you have bulimia and self-induce vomiting by sticking your fingers down your throat. If you compulsively wash your hands you might have dry, reddened and chapped hands.

These types of observations are part of your psychiatric mental status examination. The mental status exam is analogous to a physical exam - it is a record of the findings at the time of your exam. In general, the professional's observations made during your mental status examination are no different than what you observe in your normal daily interactions with friends, family and coworkers. If there was something unusual about the way someone looked, spoke or behaved you would take notice. The information has meaning to the mental health professional in that certain patterns of observation suggest certain diagnoses. These observations are diagnostic clues, but they are not conclusive. A diagnosis is not based on only a couple of clues, such as hand tremors or soft, slow speech. It is the pattern of observations, together with the history of your symptoms that help determine your diagnosis.

3. Ruling Out Physical Causes for Symptoms

The third part of the diagnostic process is to make sure that there are no physical causes of your symptoms. There are many medical diseases and medications that can produce symptoms that look psychiatric. Thyroid disease can masquerade as depression. Adrenal disease can mimic anxiety and depressive disorders. Different types of cancer can present initially as symptoms of anxiety or depression. So can HIV infection. Drug and alcohol use and withdrawal can cause psychosis, anxiety, manic and depressive symptoms. Consequently, another important part of your clinician's initial evaluation is to get a thorough medical history.

DSM-IV, The Diagnostic Bible

The current rules, or criteria, used to make your psychiatric diagnosis are published in the fourth edition of the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Mental Disorders (DSM-IV). DSM-IV is an 886-page book that lists the specific diagnostic criteria for more than 250 disorders.

What's normal and what's a psychiatric disorder?

 

Back   |   Psychiatric diagnosis